#1
16th May 2009 - 11:26 PM
Post |
|
---|---|
Hey guys I had planned on doing a big build on my rb25det out of my 33 skyline. So I ripped the engine out and I was going to get forged internals, bore the block 40thou, head porting, new gaskets, n1 oil and water pumps etc etc and go the whole lot. Now Ive been looking at the big picture, and as I am planning on keeping my highflow 33 turbo for practicality, and only doing fuel pump/injectors/computer/14psi boost and the usual mods on top I wont see much more than 300 hp anyway. Is it really worth rebuilding the motor with stronger bits for this power? I mean id be saving myself about 5k if I just did a bit of preventative maintenance now and left the motor with standard internals.... Just gimme your thoughts guys.... Cheers Jamie -------------------- |
youbUTEless 33
Post #2
300hp is not a big build anyway so i dont see any need for most of that stuff, if you can get your hands on a power fc and some spitfires, highflow is a good way to go if your not looking for massive power. |
---|
the_random_hero
Post #5
Would it be worth doing the headgasket while the engine is out?? What you guys think? Its done 100,000ish Headgaskets don't need replacing at set intervals. Not confused with having to change timing belts? |
---|
bop001
Post #6
hey mate. im in your boat too. im doing a full rebuild but with a wilder setup. |
---|
youbUTEless 33
Post #7
ohh on that note, how do you know if the belt has been done? because i have a sticker with some jap writing on it and then the number 100 000k on the cover, i bought it at 130k and i dont know if its been done, ideas? |
---|
86TX5
Post #9
Headgaskets don't need replacing at set intervals. Not confused with having to change timing belts? haha no im not confusing the headgasket with the timing belt. What im asking is if im going to be running bigger injectors/fuel pump, about 14psi blah blah blah it might be worth while replacing the gasket witha multi layer steel one. Ultimately all im aiming for is about 300 hp so it really doesnt seem worth while to spend all this money on a forged setup. And whoever pays 10k for an engine rebuild clearly isnt doing their research. I have sourced new parts to forge the block (main and head studs, pistons, rods, mls head gasket, bearings and so on) from suppliers for a total of around $3500 and talked to a well known performance shop who will assemble and race prep the whole engine, including head porting for just over $3700, or $2900 without head porting. People just dont ask around. Ive only talked to 2 shops, could prob get it done cheaper again. |
---|
09ONE
Post #10
haha no im not confusing the headgasket with the timing belt. What im asking is if im going to be running bigger injectors/fuel pump, about 14psi blah blah blah it might be worth while replacing the gasket witha multi layer steel one. Ultimately all im aiming for is about 300 hp so it really doesnt seem worth while. And whoever pays 10k for an engine rebuild clearly isnt doing their research. I have sourced new parts from suppliers for a total of about 3k and talked to a well known performance shop who will assemble and race prep the whole engine, including head porting for just under 4k. If you do it properly then $10K is about what it costs. 3K in parts??? Not using a bottom end? Either way you won't need to rebuild if you are just using a highflow. I have been through a couple of RB25's which held togeather for about a year with 380rwhp under track conditions, but 300rwhp would have seen them last a lot longer. |
---|
86TX5
Post #11
If you do it properly then $10K is about what it costs. 3K in parts??? Not using a bottom end? Either way you won't need to rebuild if you are just using a highflow. I have been through a couple of RB25's which held togeather for about a year with 380rwhp under track conditions, but 300rwhp would have seen them last a lot longer. How does it cost 10k?? Unless you are doing valve springs, cams, forged valves, turbo, intake manifold and all that shit to the head there is no way a forged bottom end with new gaskets/bearings will cost 10k with labour/assembly.. people obviosuly dont look around and just go to the first shop they come across |
---|
bop001
Post #12
How does it cost 10k?? Unless you are doing valve springs, cams, forged valves, turbo, intake manifold and all that shit to the head there is no way a forged bottom end with new gaskets/bearings will cost 10k with labour/assembly.. people obviosuly dont look around and just go to the first shop they come across pistons- 2000-3000 conrods-700- 1400 big/main end bearings= 800 ALL machine work, blueprinting, balancing, weighing, honing, boring bla bla- 1200-4000 (add more for major head work) labour including removal and fitment of engine= about 3000-4000 at MAX water pump-500 oil pump- 500-1000 crank case collar for the oil pump-100-200 timing belt- 200 belt tensioner/pulley kits etc- 200-400 oils/lubricants- 300 headstuds- 200-300 cometic head gasket- 300-400 and dont forget once its run in, it needs a service so add another 100-400. still need a calculator? and i havent even gotten into major cammage and headwork, nor turbo upgrades and associated parts. the OP only wants 300hp. so most of the above is not necessary. just keep up the mainenance. |
---|
86TX5
Post #13
ARP Head Stud Kit - $299.20 quoted |
---|
09ONE
Post #15
ARP Head Stud Kit - $299.20 quoted ARP Main Stud Kit - $286.00 quoted ACL Race Bearings (Main) - $132.00 quoted ACL Race Bearings (Big Ends) - $96.80 quoted N1 oil and water pumps - $990.00 quoted I picked up new ACL Forged pistons for $800.00 not quoted I picked up new Eagle Rods for $800.00 not quoted Timing belt kit with tensioners and pulleys, cam and crank seals - $275.00 quoted Or optional gates racing belt $120.00 quoted Cometic headgasket $300 quoted Crank case collar $100 quoted Your budget $5700 - $12,200 without servicing(already have my own oil and service my own car) and engine removal (as mentioned the engine is already out) My budget - $4079 without servicing and engine removal It took me only two emails to two different suppliers to get these quotes. I spent 3 days searching boostcruising/skylines australia and ebay to find my brand new unused pistons and rods for $800 each delivered. It just takes a little looking to get the right price, im not sayin the prices you gave me are incorrect, im sure a lot of shops do sting people for that kind of money. But you really gotta look around, why just go to the first shop you see and say build me an engine?? This sort of thing takes reseach and because I did do some research I have been able to get all my parts cheaper... anyway im not here to prove any points, just wanted to make you aware that it can easily be done for like $4,000 in parts(not $3,500 im sorry).... and as mentioned earlier $2,900 for assembly, and I have only spoken to two shops so far... Ok so you want to start crunching numbers... Firstly has your engine been built? Because mine has and there are numerous costs you are not considering. Also, your choice of parts leaves a little bit to be desired but I know you are not chasing much power. Factor in some more parts for the head, items like exhaust valve guides, stem seals or actually just a full VRS kit for the head. $600 I think you mentioned earlier as head porting? I am not exactly sure what that gets you but it's like 3-4hrs of porting. I spent 24hrs worth of porting on my head which is really fuck all in the scheme of things. And who is paying the machine costs or have they been included in the price of assembly? Machine costs can add up real quickly. It's almost impossible for the shop to quote you accurately unless they already have the engine in bits and have already sent it to the machine shop, as they won't know if your block needs to be over bored (scratched cylinder walls) or just re-honed etc. Did you make sure that the pistons you bought actually match your block (sizing are they stock or 20thou, 40thou etc) Have you checked the thickness of your head gasket and do you know the "crunch" when the head is bolted down? Have you compared your head gasket measurements including "crunch" to the pin height/deck height of the piston? You say you have done your research but there is so much more to it then just going to a shop and saying "here is my engine and some parts I bought off EBay, build me a good engine". I researched my build for over 18months before I actually started it. Do you even know what your static CR will be? |
---|
175ONN
Post #16
Ok so you want to start crunching numbers... Firstly has your engine been built? Because mine has and there are numerous costs you are not considering. Also, your choice of parts leaves a little bit to be desired but I know you are not chasing much power. Factor in some more parts for the head, items like exhaust valve guides, stem seals or actually just a full VRS kit for the head. $600 I think you mentioned earlier as head porting? I am not exactly sure what that gets you but it's like 3-4hrs of porting. I spent 24hrs worth of porting on my head which is really fuck all in the scheme of things. And who is paying the machine costs or have they been included in the price of assembly? Machine costs can add up real quickly. It's almost impossible for the shop to quote you accurately unless they already have the engine in bits and have already sent it to the machine shop, as they won't know if your block needs to be over bored (scratched cylinder walls) or just re-honed etc. Did you make sure that the pistons you bought actually match your block (sizing are they stock or 20thou, 40thou etc) Have you checked the thickness of your head gasket and do you know the "crunch" when the head is bolted down? Have you compared your head gasket measurements including "crunch" to the pin height/deck height of the piston? You say you have done your research but there is so much more to it then just going to a shop and saying "here is my engine and some parts I bought off EBay, build me a good engine". I researched my build for over 18months before I actually started it. Do you even know what your static CR will be? What he says is completely true. I'm currently in the process of rebuilding my engine, and although its not an rb25 its the same concept. You will realise when you take your engine in to get rebuilt that numerous unexpected costs will pop up. So much shit in your engine may be worn or simply stuffed and you may not know. Believe me you cannot put a price on a rebuild until like said above that its in peices at the machine shop. There is just so many variables and shit in the engine that it makes it close to impossible to predict what may or may not need to be done. Anyway my engine is costing me approximately 12gz, but thats because I have requested for extensive head work including solid lifters, valve guides, high lift cams and valve springs, they may not seem all that expensive but when the entire head consists of Tomei parts it starts to add up reall quick. If you're only aiming to rebuild your bottom end, which is pistons, rods, bearings and headgasket. I would put aside a good 6k and not expect much in return from it. This will include parts and labour. You're forgetting that when you take the head off the bottom end that it must receive a recondition and crack testing etc. This is a 100% must and costs around 600-800. Good luck. |
---|
09ONE
Post #18
What he says is completely true. I'm currently in the process of rebuilding my engine, and although its not an rb25 its the same concept. You will realise when you take your engine in to get rebuilt that numerous unexpected costs will pop up. So much shit in your engine may be worn or simply stuffed and you may not know. Believe me you cannot put a price on a rebuild until like said above that its in peices at the machine shop. There is just so many variables and shit in the engine that it makes it close to impossible to predict what may or may not need to be done. Anyway my engine is costing me approximately 12gz, but thats because I have requested for extensive head work including solid lifters, valve guides, high lift cams and valve springs, they may not seem all that expensive but when the entire head consists of Tomei parts it starts to add up reall quick. If you're only aiming to rebuild your bottom end, which is pistons, rods, bearings and headgasket. I would put aside a good 6k and not expect much in return from it. This will include parts and labour. You're forgetting that when you take the head off the bottom end that it must receive a recondition and crack testing etc. This is a 100% must and costs around 600-800. Good luck. 12G's is a good budget I think. The costs rack up at an insane rate but you know it will be worth it and to be honest this whole engine building thing is somewhat fun. I have had to "adjust" my budget 3 times during my build and each time it was by the amount the OP was looking to spend on his entire engine... |
---|
pipster11
Post #20
^^^ x2 |
---|
bop001
Post #21
disregard the above statement. u DONT NEED TO OPEN THE ENGINE. |
---|
rb30r32
Post #22
for 300 rwhp the bottom end should b fine provided the engine in not detonating. most of the rb25s ive seen pushing 400rwhp dont seem 2 last very long(not saying all) . an rb25 engine that is making300rwhp may only last 1 drive if severe detination was present, where as its probly possible to push a rb25 to 400rwhp for a year or 2 and have no issues. when u hear that pinging sound. (u cant always) just think of it as a hammer smashing into ur pistons . personally i keep an eye on detonation with a knock detector around 250 bucks . witch is bugger all compared 2 a 10,000 dollar engine. |
---|
86TX5
Post #23
Sounds good. I basically just wanted a guideline to what I need and dont. But im quite clear on what the rb25 can handle now after doing a bit more homework. Its getting water pump/timing belt/ heavy duty clutch/ engine mounts (shagged) and a few gaskets here and there. Then il slap her back in! |
---|
isajlo101
Post #25
Hey guys I had planned on doing a big build on my rb25det out of my 33 skyline. So I ripped the engine out and I was going to get forged internals, bore the block 40thou, head porting, new gaskets, n1 oil and water pumps etc etc and go the whole lot. Now Ive been looking at the big picture, and as I am planning on keeping my highflow 33 turbo for practicality, and only doing fuel pump/injectors/computer/14psi boost and the usual mods on top I wont see much more than 300 hp anyway. Is it really worth rebuilding the motor with stronger bits for this power? I mean id be saving myself about 5k if I just did a bit of preventative maintenance now and left the motor with standard internals.... Just gimme your thoughts guys.... Cheers Jamie Hey Jamie - I have a 93 Skyline GTST with the RB25DET motor still stock, the stock gearbox and diff. All I have done is added a new Plazmaman inlet manifold, Plenum intercooler piping kit, Plazmaman billet fuel rail upgrade, THR injectors, HKS camshaft, HKS cam gears (slide pulley), Link Atom G4 ECU, High rise turbo manifold with Garrett turbo (Toned down to 14 psi), custom dump pipe, custom intake piping, High flow Cat converter, custom intercooler piping - Dyno pulled 290 Kilowatts (388 Horsepower). If the motor was forged and the gearbox, clutch and diff upgraded would be pulling close to 600 horsepower, I guess thats the next build. Regards Izzy |
---|
If you have a BoostCruising account enter your user name and password into the yellow box.
Alternatively, you can quickly login with Facebook.
If you don't have an account create one below.
Create AccountLogin using your Facebook account!